Book 36: Dark Force Rising by Timothy Zahn

What's this?  A Star Wars book?  Yes, I felt it was time for a bit of fluff.  I like to read a few of these kinds of books now and then just for fun.  The series (this is the second book) starts about 5 years after The Return of the Jedi and continues the story from there.  Other than the original films, these are the best Star Wars stories I know of.  Instead of the prequel trilogy, Lucas should have filmed these.  I've read this set a long time ago and wanted to re-read them.  Before my little project here started I read the novelization of the prequel movies, the original movies and these seemed like the logical place to go from there.

At 440 pages it's only 63 pages per day.  Shouldn't really be a problem.


REVIEW:

This is the second of the Thrawn trilogy of Star Wars books.  It picks up where the last left off.  Leia and Chewbacca are on a mission to try to recruit a mysterious species for the New Republic while Luke, Han and Lando are searching for a long lost fleet of starships that could turn the course of the conflict between them and the remnants of the Empire.

The best part of these books are the characters.  Zahn writes the heroes exactly as you remember them from the movies.  Their personalities fit perfectly.  His new characters, especially his villain, Grand Admiral Thrawn, are well fleshed-out and believable with realistic personalities and motives.  Thrawn as a villain is way above what you would expect from a Star Wars novel.  He is well-cultured, subtle, intelligent and devious.  There are plenty of times when the heroes are one step ahead of him, but many other moments that he outwits them.

There are plenty of plots and counterplots to weave, on both sides, in this book.  It reads as a kind of treasure hunt.  Both sides are looking for the same thing, the Dark Force, a fleet of 200 powerful dreadnoughts, and they bounce around the galaxy following leads and false-leads.  As the end of the book approaches it turns into a race, the victor of which may tilt the balance of power in their favor.

Another thing that I particularly like is the level of detail included in Zahn's universe.  Zahn describes things like spacecraft controls, weapons effects and even Luke's Jedi powers in very believable and engaging ways.  It makes the experience much more immersive when these details are done right.

Overall, the book is a lot of fun.  The characters are accurate and familiar, the villain is sufficiently devious and challenging and the action is non-stop.  If they would make this trilogy into movies it would be many times better than Episodes 1-3.

9 out of 10.

Book 35: A Dance with Dragons by George R.R. Martin

I'm back on schedule now and ready to get back into this series.  I nearly burned myself out on it when I read the first four books in one month.  At around a thousand pages each, that was a bit much.  I'm eager to read this one because the last one felt a bit like half a book.  The author, instead of showing half the story for all the characters, decided to show all the story for half the characters.  Unfortunately, the characters that I really enjoyed were, for the most part, absent from the last book.  This one should show the events surrounding those missing characters and, hopefully, advance the plot a bit further.  I know that he plans at least 2 more books in this series, so I'm not expecting a resolution, but we'll see where he goes with it.

1040 pages means about 150 pages per day, quite a lot.

REVIEW:  As I mentioned before, the previous book in this series, A Feast for Crows, followed the stories for most of the characters in the Seven Kingdoms.  This book follows the stories of the remaining characters, most of them either at The Wall or across the Narrow Sea in the Free Cities.  This was good for me because the characters that this book focused on happen to be some of my favorites.  Tyrion, Jon Snow, Daenerys and Arya were all there and it was good to catch up with them.  What look to be some momentous changes are also beginning in this book.  Jon Snow has taken charge and is putting that authority to use and Daenerys’ dragons are finally starting to show their power.  Once Martin has brought the narratives int his book up to the time of those in the previous book he starts to show us how some of them may eventually tie together.  It’s just a tease, but it’s definitely starting to look like something more than just a lot of random character plots.

Unfortunately, his writing style has not much improved.  More than anything, it seems like he just needs  a more assertive editor.  He has a tendency to use repetitive descriptive phrases such as the dreaded “useless as nipples on a breastplate.”  He also has entire chapters of questionable relevance.  It’s admirable that he’d want to flesh out his side characters and their motives but, ultimately, it doesn’t matter.  It just serves to detract from the real action.  These overelaborations and the distractions of skipping around so much between chapters drag the plot to a snail’s pace.  He reminds me of Robert Jordan, the writer of the Wheel of Time series.  Jordan would spend an entire 800-900 page book moving an army from one city to the next with the only action at the very end.  Which, of course, is another problem here. Because this is the middle of the series, there is no resolution to any of the plot-lines.  Martin's series is not like Jordan's where there is a fight with one of the "little bad guys" at the end of each book.  It is the middle of a single, very long narrative.  Like chapter 40 through 70 of some 20,000 page epic.

Overall, the book is slowpaced and meandering, though there is still a sense that, somewhere in the future, the many, many threads that Martin has woven will come together to form a whole.  I can't say that the series is my favorite of all time, but it is still in the top ten and I will continue to read the sequels when they are released, if only to see where all this is leading.

7 out of 10.

Book 34: The Adventure of English by Melvyn Bragg

As a former linguistics student, I still have a lasting love of languages.  English, I think, is one of the most interesting languages, though it's difficult to see sometimes, as we're all native speakers here in the U.S.  But even here, people are mystified by the strangeness of the language.  People ask themselves, why do we pronounce this set of letters one way in this word, but in another word it's pronounced differently.  Well, a lot of the inconsistency and seeming randomness comes from the strange and turbulent history of English.  This book traces that history in a novel fashion, that of a biography of the language itself.  I'm unsure how successful this approach will be, but I couldn't resist the title when I first heard of it.  At 299 pages, it shouldn't be too hard to finish at around 43 pages per day.

REVIEW:  This book definitely delivered what I expected of it.  The author, Bragg, traces the history of the language with each chapter outlining one significant stage in the evolution of English.  He shows Alfred the Great, defeating the Danes and unifying England, the revolt against the Church and Latin by William Tyndale and his English Bible, the rise of English literature with Chaucer and Shakespeare, Samuel Johnson writing his dictionary but, overall, his main character is the language itself.  There were multiple points where English could have simply gone extinct.  When the Danes invaded England they nearly wiped out the English speaking natives, when the Normans invaded they imposed their French language on the land, but it was the "deep obstinacy" and "astonishing flexibility" that enabled the language to survive and eventually thrive.

It is interesting to see the course of a language all at once.  And it's difficult to think of another language with a similar history to English.  Beginning with the Anglo-Saxon invasion of England, who were themselves invaded by the Vikings and Normans, then the consolidation of British English and then outward to America, India, Australia, the West Indies and beyond.  Now, some 1,500 years later the language is spoken by some 1 billion people, worldwide and is established as the modern Lingua Franca.  And it is the amazing ability of English to adapt, to repair and reinvent itself that seems to have made it possible.

As a linguist, I've always been fascinated with our aberrant language and the reasons that it makes so little sense to non-speakers and learning speakers.  We follow grammatical rules that we hardly understand; We have words that are pronounced nothing like their spelling; We have multiple sets of rules for conjugating verbs, etc.  It is illuminating to see the tumultuous history of the language, not to see that there really is an underlying logic to these things, but to see that there are good reasons that it makes so little sense.  The book did get a little dry in places, after all, it is historical linguistics in essence, but Bragg does a commendable job of making it all make sense as a single narrative.

7 out of 10

Book 33: The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen by Alan Moore and Kevin O'Neill

I'm cheating again and still haven't finished Pasternak in Russian.  However, in order to try to keep up with the project I'm reading another book over the weekend.  This time it's a graphic novel, actually a collection of graphic novels consisting of the first two volumes of the comic with 6 issues in each volume.  Since so many films, etc. are based on comics and graphic novels these days I thought I would try to work in a few to round out my reading.  There are no page numbers in this book, but it looks to be about 250-270 pages and I should be able to finish within 2-3 days.

REVIEW:  I really wanted the movie version of this to be good but it really just wasn’t.  I figured that, maybe, the source material would be better and there I wasn’t disappointed.  This omnibus version of the material contains the first two volumes along with a couple of prose stories in between them.  Each volume contains six of the original issues. 

The story revolves around a group of literary “superheroes” for lack of a better word.  The League consists of 5 characters, Mina Harker from Dracula, Allan Quatermain from King Solomon’s Mines, Dr. Jeckyll and his alter-ego, Hawley Griffin a.k.a. the Invisible Man and Captain Nemo (do I really need to tell you what where he’s from?).  The five “superheroes” band together to help the government of England defeat some of the biggest challenges facing it.

It’s an interesting concept, and the main characters are not the only ones from fictional sources to be included.  There are characters galore from Edgar Rice Burroughs, Edgar Allan Poe, Jules Verne, H.G. Wells, H.P. Lovecraft and many, many others both famous and obscure.  In fact, it was sort of a side-game for me to try to identify even minor characters and their sources. 

I did have a couple of problems with the book.  The ending of the second volume is a little unsatisfying, but that’s not really a big deal.  My main problem is with the two main protagonists, Mina Murray (Harker) and Allan Quatermain.  It seemed to me that neither one of them really did much of anything.  Quatermain was aghast at just about everything that happens and behaves rather cowardly most of the time.  Mina tries to keep the group focused and is, supposedly the brains of the operation, but she doesn’t really do anything either.  Quatermain is supposed to be a great hunter but doesn’t shoot anything and Mina is, supposedly, a vampire but never even defends herself when attacked.  All the real action is left to the other three members of the League.

Overall, the story moves at a good pace, the art is good and the plot is interesting.  It was definitely much better than the film.  Of the two prose sections, the first is a prologue about Allan Quatermain and was relatively interesting, but the second is a sort of travelogue of the world showing how full of random literary places and people it is.  Somehow that failed to be interesting and came across as kind of dry. 

7 out of 10.

Book 32: Murder on the Orient Express by Agatha Christie

I'm cheating on my little project here as the Russian book is giving me a harder time than expected.  I should have finished by now but am only about 160 pages in.  I'm going on a weekend vacation and don't really feel like working through Pasternak, so I'm taking a little break and reading a murder mystery.  It's pretty short at 256 pages and I'll probably try to finish it by the end of the long weekend so about 85 pages per day. 

REVIEW:  This is the second Agatha Christie mystery that I’ve read and I was impressed with this one as well.  I have this little game that I like to play with mystery novels where I write down a list of suspects and, every quarter of the book or so, I try to guess who is the guilty party.  I find that my choice generally changes as more evidence is uncovered.  I generally take it as a sign of a good mystery if the crime is solvable at the end of the book without additional “clues” being introduced at the last minute.  Christie is really good at laying out all of the information but still surprising you at the end.  Twice now, I’ve played my little game and didn’t even come close to guessing the guilty party.

This book wasn’t quite as good as the previous one I read as I felt the ending was a little bit unfair but that may just be sour grapes because she got me again.  I do really like the character of Hercule Poirot and I’m wondering if I would like her other main character, Miss Marple, as much.  Maybe I’ll explore that next.

Overall, it was a great little mystery and another interesting read.  I suppose there’s a reason that Agatha Christie has sold over 2 billion books.  It wasn’t quite as good as The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, however as the ending felt a little contrived and the mystery was laid out a bit too clinically. 

7 out of 10.

Book 31: Doctor Zhivago by Boris Pasternak

This one is going to be a challenge.  I decided last time around that, if I speak the language in which the book is written, I should read the book in that language.  I did this with The Three Musketeers in French, but Russian is a more difficult language, so I've been shying away from it.

I'm determined this time, though, and I'm going to try to read the Russian version of the book.  One plus side of this is that, in trying to procure a Russian version, I found that my library has an original, 1st edition copy of the book.  It's not in great condition, but there's something cool about knowing that, when Pasternak first published Doctor Zhivago, this is one of the copies that rolled off the presses.

566 pages in this one which would be about 81 pages per day, but I'll be lucky to get half of that number... I'm going to need to make up time once I finish this one.

Review:  Wow!  This one took me a lot longer than anticipated.  Instead of one week it took a total of three weeks to plod my way through it.  At first, I started with the book and a dictionary and was looking up 3-5 words per page, it was taking a long time.  Near the end, I was able to go many pages without having to resort to the dictionary but my reading speed was still pretty low.  Pasternak's writing, it turns out, is quite poetic and therefore very dense.  I am glad that I made the effort, however.  I feel that the practice really improved my Russian reading skills and it was good to read the book in it's original language.

Being unfamiliar with the material, either the book or the films, I was under a wrong impression of this book.  I thought that it was going to be a very romanticized love story between Dr. Zhivago and his love, Lara, set against the Russian Revolution of 1917.  In this way, I thought that it would be much closer in tone and content as something like Anna Karenina.  It turns out, however, that this is not the case.  The story follows Dr. Yuri Zhivago from his youth through his adulthood and his trials during the revolution.  He grows up, marries, is conscripted, released, reunites with his family, is shanghai'd again, escapes, etc. During this time, he is also in love with Lara Guishar, who moves in and out of his life multiple times.  At first, their relationship evolves as events push them around and eventually they depend on each other for support more than any fierce passion.  In this way, the book reminds me more of War and Peace or Gone with the Wind than Anna Karenina.  It's a love story, but one in which the main characters are almost lost amongst the huge, dramatic events unfolding around them.

I liked the book quite a bit, even though it was hard work getting through it.  The writing was beautiful, especially in Russian, and the characters were very likable.  The story was engaging and never really slowed down and you are engaged with Yuri's fate every step of the way.  I would highly recommend anyone to read this book.  Doing it in Russian was merely a challenge for myself and certainly not necessary.

8 out of 10

Book 30: Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince

I'm back to Harry Potter.  I can tell that this series is good because I'm always excited to get back to it and, here it is, the penultimate book.  The last book fully evolved the theme into it's more adult, darker tone and I'm sure this one will continue in that way.  People tell me that it's a really good book, and I haven't seen the movie for this one yet either, so the entire plot should be a surprise for me.

It's a little bit shorter than the last installment at 652 pages.  To complete it in one week would be 94 pages per day, but I tend to read these obsessively so I may finish ahead of time.

REVIEW: Another great installment of the Harry Potter series.  The thing I liked best about this book was the pace.  Because the plot is now revealed and Lord Voldemort is now acting openly, Rowling is free to advance things much more quickly.  Harry has grown out of his petulant phase and it much more trusting of his friends, Dumbledore is now acting in a much more direct and less mysterious manner and even Harry’s classwork seems to be much more focused and useful.

I like the pace that I’m going through these books as well.  I’m reading them about 10 weeks apart as I cycle through other genres and it builds up the suspense nicely.  I’m glad that I didn’t read them when they were first released or it would be a year or two between books. 

The whole reason that I started reading these books is that I felt that there was too much missing from the movie versions.  I wondered what became of Harry’s first love interest, Cho, and how his romance wth Ginny started.  I also wanted to know more about characters like Luna Lovegood and Neville Longbottom.  I have been completely satisfied with the books in that regard.  I have even come to like the house elves. 

The book is so full of surprises that I can’t really say much more without spoiling things, but I’m really impressed with the growth of Rowling’s writing and the overall plot of the books.  Harry Potter has definitely justified all the hype that surrounded the series and then some.  I’m looking forward to the final chapter in the story.

9 out of 10.